Find the 3 Best Hotels in Fish Creek, WI

By The Bay Motel offers boutique accommodations in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, featuring 15 renovated rooms and The Deckhouse vacation rental. Our property combines modern amenities, waterfront views, and self-check-in technology. We provide direct beach access and proximity to Door County attractions.

Main Street Motel provides family-owned accommodations in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, offering 31 uniquely decorated rooms with modern amenities. Located steps from Lake Michigan and local attractions, we combine Midwestern hospitality with Door County charm. Our seasonal operations (May-October) focus on creating memorable stays through clean, comfortable lodging and personalized guest experiences.

Thorp House Inn & Cottages is a historic bed and breakfast in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, offering elegantly appointed rooms and private cottages with modern amenities. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, we provide a serene base for exploring Door Countys scenic landscapes, cultural attractions, and outdoor activities. Our TripAdvisor #1-rated service includes daily homemade breakfasts and personalized attention to ensure unforgettable stays.