Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Waterfront Getaway in Fish Creek, WI
By The Bay Motel stands as Door County's premier boutique accommodation destination, offering a unique blend of modern luxury and historic charm. Since our 2023 renovations under new ownership, we've elevated the guest experience with fully upgraded interiors, smart technology integration, and enhanced amenities that honor our property's 80-year legacy in Fish Creek. Our prime location places guests steps from downtown shops, restaurants, and Fish Creek Beach while providing uninterrupted water views of Peninsula State Park. We specialize in combining self-guided convenience through mobile check-in technology with personalized service that reflects our deep roots in the Door County community.Our property features two meticulously maintained buildings with 15 thoughtfully designed rooms and The Deckhouse - a five-bedroom vacation rental with premium finishes and exclusive amenities like private decks and an in-house sauna. We maintain historic integrity while delivering contemporary comforts, ensuring every guest receives the highest standard of hospitality in a setting that seamlessly merges natural beauty with modern sophistication.
Services
The Deckhouse
Motel Rooms
Self Check-In
Pet-Friendly Stays
Waterfront Amenities
Details
- Year established: 1940
Highlights and features
- We offer mobile self-check-in technology for seamless arrivals
- Our property maintains historic character with modern amenities
- We provide exclusive access to Fish Creek Harbor views
- Our 2023 renovations introduced luxury hospitality-grade products
- We maintain proximity to downtown Fish Creek's attractions
What people say
Breathtaking water views
Modern renovated interiors
Convenient self-check-in
Historic charm maintained
Proximity to attractions
Services
The Deckhouse
Our luxury five-bedroom vacation rental accommodates ten guests with premium amenities. Features include private decks, an in-house sauna, and uninterrupted views of Fish Creek Harbor. All rooms feature modern furnishings and upscale bath products.
Motel Rooms
15 fully renovated rooms across two historic buildings offer comfortable accommodations. Rooms include smart TVs, modern furnishings, and select options with harbor views. Available configurations include king, queen, and double queen setups.
Self Check-In
Experience seamless arrivals with our smartphone-based check-in. Access digital keys, property guides, and customer service through your mobile device for expedited check-in/check-out processes.
Pet-Friendly Stays
We accommodate pets in designated rooms. Guests receive special amenities while maintaining our cleanliness standards. Please confirm pet policy details during booking or contact us directly for specific requirements.
Waterfront Amenities
Enjoy direct beach access and waterfront patios with fire pit. The property offers scenic views of Peninsula State Park with designated spaces for relaxation and recreation just steps from Fish Creek Harbor.
Questions
What is the self-check-in process?
Our mobile check-in system allows guests to complete booking, check-in, and access instructions via smartphone. You'll receive digital keys and property information before arrival.
What amenities are available at Fresh Coast Motel?
We offer private decks, an in-house sauna in The Deckhouse, a waterfront fire pit, high-speed Wi-Fi, Smart TVs, and premium bath products. Our location provides direct beach access.
What types of accommodations do you offer?
We have two buildings with 15 standard rooms and The Deckhouse - a five-bedroom vacation rental. Room types include king, queen, and two-queen configurations with water views available.
How close are you to downtown Fish Creek?
Our property is located directly on Fish Creek's main strip, offering walking distance access to shops, restaurants, and the public beach across the street.
Is Fresh Coast Motel pet-friendly?
Yes, we welcome pets in designated rooms. Please review our pet policy during booking or contact us directly for specific requirements and restrictions.
