Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Lakeside Escape in Bayfield, Wisconsin
At Seagull Bay, we offer a unique blend of old-school charm and modern design along the Lake Superior shoreline. Established in 1940, our family-owned business has been revitalized by Isaac and Mollie Carrier since 2017, preserving the nostalgic essence while enhancing comfort. Our three propertiesSeagull Bay Motel, Bay West, and The Brownstone Cottageprovide direct access to the Brownstone Trail, connecting guests to Bayfields shops, restaurants, and cultural events. We prioritize a serene, home-like atmosphere where guests can unwind, explore outdoor adventures, or attend local attractions like the Big Top Chautauqua.With decades of combined hospitality experience, we ensure personalized service, clean accommodations, and unforgettable views of Lake Superior. Our commitment to quality is reflected in guest testimonials praising our attention to detail, peaceful ambiance, and thoughtful amenities. We aim to create a space where visitors feel connected to nature and the community while enjoying modern comforts.
Services
Lakeside Motel Rooms
Cottages
Guesthouse Rentals
Trail Access
Event Shuttle Service
Seasonal Adventure Guide
Pet-Friendly Stays
Kitchenette Accommodations
Scenic Balcony Views
Local Area Tours
Details
- Year established: 1940
Highlights and features
- Family-owned with personalized, attentive service since 2017.
- Direct access to the Brownstone Trail for easy town exploration.
- Free shuttle to Big Top Chautauqua events during summer months.
- Clean, modernized rooms with sweeping views of Lake Superior.
- Historic yet updated properties preserving nostalgic Midwest charm.
What people say
Old-fashioned charm
Sweeping lake views
Free shuttle service
Clean and charming
Peaceful atmosphere
Services
Lakeside Motel Rooms
Our motel rooms offer cozy, modernized accommodations with private or shared balconies overlooking Lake Superior. Each room blends vintage charm with updated amenities like free Wi-Fi and kitchenettes. Guests enjoy easy access to the Brownstone Trail and seasonal shuttle service to local events, making it ideal for travelers seeking both relaxation and adventure.
Cottages
Spacious cottages sleep up to six guests, featuring full kitchens, bunkrooms, and expansive decks. These family-friendly units combine rustic elements with modern comforts like mid-century design accents. Located steps from the shoreline, they provide a private retreat for groups or families exploring Bayfields orchards, festivals, and outdoor activities.
Event Shuttle Service
Enjoy complimentary shuttle access to Big Top Chautauqua shows during summer months. This service connects our parking lot directly to Mount Ashwabay, ensuring hassle-free attendance at concerts and cultural events. It reflects our commitment to enhancing guest experiences beyond accommodation.
Seasonal Adventure Guide
We provide a curated seasonal guide to Bayfields best activities, from kayaking in Apostle Islands to apple-picking at family orchards. The downloadable resource helps guests plan itineraries tailored to their interests, ensuring they maximize their Lake Superior getaway with insider knowledge.
Scenic Balcony Views
Every property offers balconies or decks with unobstructed vistas of Lake Superior and the Apostle Islands. These spaces are designed for morning coffee, sunset watching, or quiet reading, emphasizing our focus on connecting guests to the natural beauty of the Midwests rugged coastline.
People
Isaac Carrier
Co-Owner & Operator
Isaac Carrier co-owns Seagull Bay with his wife Mollie. A Bayfield native, he transitioned from firefighting to hospitality in 2017, prioritizing hands-on management and guest relationships. He oversees property operations and restoration projects.
Mollie Carrier
Co-Owner & Operator
Mollie Carrier co-owns Seagull Bay and manages guest services alongside Isaac. A former hair and makeup artist, she brings creative flair to hospitality, focusing on comfort and attention to detail. She balances family life with running the business.
Questions
What is Seagull Bay’s location?
We’re at 325 South 7th St, Bayfield, WI 54814, directly above Lake Superior with views of the Apostle Islands.
Do rooms have lake views?
All properties offer Lake Superior views from private or shared balconies, decks, or windows.
How do I access the Brownstone Trail?
The trail is steps from our properties, offering a scenic walk to Bayfield’s shops and restaurants.
Is there a shuttle to local events?
Yes, we provide a free summer shuttle to Big Top Chautauqua shows from our parking lot.
Are pets allowed?
Pet-friendly options are available; contact us directly to arrange accommodations for your pet.
What nearby activities are recommended?
Guests enjoy kayaking, orchard tours, Big Top concerts, and exploring the Apostle Islands’ lighthouses.
