Business Details
36 Years
experience
WELCOME TO The Lake Ontario Motel
Lake Ontario Motel has been a trusted hospitality provider in Niagara County since 1990. Our family-owned establishment combines historical charm with modern comforts, offering guests a peaceful retreat near major Western New York attractions. Strategically located between Lake Ontario, the Erie Canal, and Niagara Falls, we cater to diverse travelers including anglers, families, and business professionals. Our property features contactless check-in options during select seasons, pet-friendly accommodations, and specialized amenities for fishing enthusiasts. With over three decades of service, we maintain a reputation for cleanliness, affordability, and personalized guest experiences.Our owners, Brad and Paige May, bring extensive local knowledge and hospitality expertise, continuing a family legacy that began with Paige's parents, Jan and Phil Toenniessen. The property's unique history as a 1910 barn-turned-motel adds character to our 12-room facility, which includes modern renovations while preserving original architectural elements. We actively support local tourism initiatives and maintain memberships in regional business associations to better serve our community.
Services
Accommodations
Fishing Lodging
Contactless Check-In
Pet-Friendly Stays
Niagara Falls Access
Details
- Year established: 1990
Highlights and features
- Over 30 years serving Niagara County travelers since 1990
- Pet-friendly accommodations with dedicated fishing amenities
- Contactless check-in available during winter seasons
- Direct access to Lake Ontario's world-class fishing spots
- Family-owned with generations of local community involvement
What people say
Great clean place
Very friendly people
Cute accommodations
Reasonable rates
Pet-friendly policy
Services
Accommodations
Our 12 modernized rooms combine comfort with functionality, featuring contactless check-in options during winter months. Each room maintains historical charm while offering contemporary amenities like free WiFi and climate control. Guests enjoy easy access to Lake Ontario's recreational opportunities and Niagara Falls' attractions.
Fishing Lodging
Specialized accommodations for fishing enthusiasts include boat parking, freezer storage for catches, and proximity to Lake Ontario's renowned salmon/trout fisheries. Our staff provides local knowledge about nearby fishing spots like Eighteen Mile Creek and the Erie Canal.
Pet-Friendly Stays
We welcome pets with designated accommodations that maintain cleanliness standards for all guests. Pet owners receive specific guidelines during booking to ensure comfortable stays for both animals and human visitors.
Niagara Falls Access
Convenient 30-minute access to both American and Canadian sides of Niagara Falls. Our central location between Lake Ontario and the Erie Canal provides optimal positioning for exploring Western New York's major attractions.
Contactless Check-In
Winter season guests receive automated check-in details via text/email on arrival day. This streamlined process operates December 1st through April 17th, reducing front-desk interactions while maintaining security protocols.
People
Brad May
Co-Owner
Co-owner Brad May manages daily operations with 5+ years hospitality experience. Former sales manager for precision manufacturing, he brings business acumen to our family-run establishment.
Paige May
Co-Owner
Co-owner Paige May combines dental hygiene expertise with hospitality management. As third-generation proprietor, she maintains family legacy since acquiring the property in 2018.
Phil Toenniessen
Previous Owner
Phil established local fishing tourism credentials over 17 years operating Lake Ontario charters. His maritime expertise shaped our motel's angler-focused amenities and community connections.
Jan Toenniessen
Former Proprietor
Jan contributed decades of tourism experience through Niagara County board memberships. Her hospitality insights helped transform the historic property into a modern lodging destination.
Questions
What check-in options are available?
We offer contactless check-in via text/email December 1st - April 17th. Standard check-in available other dates with advance notice.
Are pets allowed on premises?
Yes, we provide designated pet-friendly rooms with specific guidelines to ensure all guests' comfort.
How close are you to Niagara Falls?
We're 30 minutes from both American and Canadian Niagara Falls attractions.
Do you accept credit card payments?
Payment options listed during booking process. Contact us directly for specific payment inquiries.
What fishing amenities do you provide?
We offer boat parking, freezer storage for catches, and local fishing spot recommendations for Lake Ontario anglers.
What's the property's history?
Originally built as a 1910 barn, converted to motel in 1990 while preserving original architectural elements like hand-hewn beams.
