Business Details
Your Vintage Retreat in the Finger Lakes
We are a historic motor lodge in Ithaca, New York, offering unique accommodations since the early 20th century. Our 16 rooms and cottages blend mid-century design with modern amenities, including pet-friendly options and a vintage 1964 Shasta camper. We provide immersive experiences through walking trails, fire pits, and proximity to Finger Lakes attractions like Buttermilk Falls and Robert H. Treman State Parks. Our team, led by owners Alexis and Mark, prioritizes sustainability and historic preservation while delivering personalized service.With over 11 acres of grounds, we cater to travelers seeking comfort, nature, and local culture. Our amenities include regional breakfast offerings, event spaces for weddings and retreats, and curated on-site retail. We maintain transparent policies for guests, emphasizing accessibility and community engagement through partnerships with local businesses and conservation efforts.
Services
Accommodations
Event Hosting
Catering Services
Souvenir Shop
Breakfast Service
Pet-Friendly Stays
Meeting Spaces
Campground
Local Tours
Bar Service
Highlights and features
- We offer 100+ years of hospitality experience in a historic Finger Lakes property
- Our 11-acre grounds feature walking trails, fire pits, and bird watching habitats
- Pet-friendly accommodations available in select mid-century designed rooms and cottages
- Direct access to Finger Lakes hiking, swimming, and state park attractions
- We host unique events with exclusive property access for weddings and retreats
Services
Accommodations
We provide 16 uniquely designed rooms and cottages blending mid-century aesthetics with modern comforts. Our options include pet-friendly spaces, kitchenettes, and a vintage 1964 Shasta camper. Each room features period fixtures, natural bath products, and complimentary Wi-Fi while maintaining historic authenticity.
Event Hosting
Our 11-acre property offers exclusive event access for weddings, retreats, and gatherings. We accommodate 50 overnight guests with multiple venues including a woodland chapel, patio, and retro Pine Porch. Our team assists with catering arrangements and liquor licensing for special events.
Catering Services
We coordinate full-service catering for breakfast, lunch, or dinner through preferred local vendors. Our reception bar provides regional beverages including craft beer, wine, and cider. A 15% service charge applies to all catering arrangements managed through our staff.
Souvenir Shop
Our on-site shop offers curated Finger Lakes merchandise including custom mugs, key fobs, and canvas tote bags. Seasonal items like annual pumpkin carving tickets are available. All purchases support local artisans and our property preservation efforts.
Breakfast Service
Complimentary continental breakfast features locally sourced cheeses, meats, and baked goods. Freshly brewed coffee and regional beverages are served daily from 8:00 AM to 10:30 AM in our Reception/Bar area. Guests may pre-order snack kits for in-room consumption.
People
Alexis
Co-Owner
Co-steward of Grayhaven Motel with six years of property rehabilitation experience. Focuses on historic preservation and guest experience while maintaining the property's original charm.
Mark
Co-Owner
Co-owns Grayhaven Motel with Alexis. Leads conservation efforts and grounds maintenance across the 11-acre property while ensuring modern amenities complement historic elements.
Questions
What room types are available at Grayhaven Motel?
We offer 16 rooms including mid-century designed doubles, kings, queens, suites, and a 1964 Shasta camper. Options include pet-friendly accommodations and fully equipped cottages.
Can I book the entire property for an event?
Yes, we offer exclusive property access for weddings, retreats, and events with capacity for 50 overnight guests and multiple indoor/outdoor venues.
Are pets allowed at the motel?
Yes, select rooms in Treman Lodge and West Point Cottages accept pets. Please specify pet requirements when booking to ensure proper accommodations.
What dining options exist on-site?
We provide continental breakfast, regional beverage service, and snack kits. Our bar offers local beer, wine, and cider with outdoor consumption permitted in designated areas.
What outdoor amenities are available?
Our 11-acre property features walking trails, fire pits, bocce court, croquet, hammocks, and bird watching habitats near Finger Lakes state parks.
