Business Details
Your Historic Stay in Sharon Springs, NY
The American Hotel stands as a testament to historic preservation and modern hospitality in Sharon Springs, New York. Since our restoration, we have dedicated ourselves to providing guests with an immersive experience that blends 19th-century charm with contemporary comforts. Our nine individually appointed guest rooms feature private baths, smart TVs, and curated amenities designed to ensure a relaxing stay. The hotels restaurant, now open for dinner Thursday through Monday, offers a refined menu rooted in local flavors, complemented by a welcoming pub and outdoor garden spaces.We prioritize personalized service, evident in our attentive staff and made-to-order breakfasts, which have become a hallmark of our guest experience. Located on Sharon Springs Main Street, we serve as a gateway to regional attractions like Cooperstown and Glimmerglass State Park while maintaining a strong commitment to preserving the architectural heritage of our community. Our teams expertise in historic restoration and hospitality ensures every visitor enjoys both comfort and authenticity.
Services
Lodging
Breakfast Service
Dining
Private Events
Accessibility Features
Highlights and features
- We offer 9 individually appointed guest rooms with modern amenities in a historic setting.
- Our restaurant provides farm-to-table dining Thursday through Monday with seasonal brunch options.
- We maintain ADA-compliant and pet-friendly accommodations for diverse guest needs.
- Our staff offers personalized recommendations for exploring Sharon Springs and nearby attractions.
- We guarantee a 100% satisfaction rate on breakfast quality and room cleanliness.
What people say
Delicious breakfast
Kind and welcoming owner
Beautiful and charming
Excellent service
Perfect weekend getaway
Services
Lodging
Our nine guest rooms combine historic charm with modern comforts like smart TVs, free WiFi, and mini refrigerators. Each room features unique decor and private bathrooms with Beekman 1802 bath products. ADA-compliant and pet-friendly options ensure accessibility for all guests.
Breakfast Service
Start your day with made-to-order breakfast featuring ricotta pancakes, French toast, and seasonal specialties. Dietary restrictions are accommodated, and meals can be enjoyed in our dining room or on the patio. Our Stagecoach Coffee blend is available 24/7.
Dining
Our restaurant serves dinner Thursday through Monday with a menu highlighting local ingredients and Southern influences. Weekend brunch launches seasonally. The bar offers craft cocktails and a cozy fireplace setting, while outdoor seating is available on our perennial patio.
Private Events
Host weddings, festivals, or corporate gatherings in our historic venue. Recent events include the Sharon Springs Poetry Festival Dinner. Our team coordinates logistics for up to 50 guests in our elegantly restored dining room and outdoor spaces.
Accessibility Features
We provide ADA-compliant rooms with grab bars, wheelchair-accessible sinks, and first-floor porch access. Digital accessibility improvements ensure seamless online booking and information access for guests with disabilities.
People
Michael Palaia
Co-Owner
Co-owner Michael Palaia oversees daily operations and guest relations. With a background in historic preservation, he ensures the hotel maintains its architectural integrity while delivering modern hospitality standards.
Marco Braeutigam
Co-Owner
Marco Braeutigam co-owns the hotel and focuses on culinary programming. He leads menu development for breakfast and dinner services, emphasizing seasonal and regional ingredients in our revitalized restaurant.
John
Chef
Chef John prepares made-to-order breakfasts and dinner specials. Known for his vegan breakfast sausage and crab cake expertise, he brings decades of culinary experience to our kitchen.
Linda
Server
Linda provides attentive table service during breakfast and dinner. Guests praise her warmth and local knowledge, which enhance the dining experience with personalized recommendations for the area.
Garth
Innkeeper
Garth previously managed guest relations as an innkeeper. He contributed to the hotels restoration and maintained its reputation for hospitality before transitioning ownership to the current team.
Questions
What room amenities are available?
All rooms include private baths, smart TVs with Hulu, mini refrigerators, and free WiFi. ADA-compliant and pet-friendly options are available.
Does the hotel offer dining options?
Yes! Our restaurant serves dinner Thursday-Monday, with weekend brunch launching seasonally. Breakfast is included and made to order daily.
Can I book a reservation online?
Reservations can be made online through our website or by calling 518-284-2105 for same-day bookings.
Are pets allowed?
Yes, select rooms are pet-friendly. Please specify when booking to ensure proper accommodations.
What nearby attractions are accessible?
We’re steps from Beekman 1802 and McGillycuddy’s shops. Cooperstown’s Baseball Hall of Fame is a 30-minute drive, and Glimmerglass State Park is 15 minutes away.
Is the hotel accessible for guests with disabilities?
Yes. We offer ADA-compliant rooms with grab bars, wheelchair-accessible sinks, and digital accessibility improvements for online services.
